Not too bad, but I've tasted better carrot cakes. Perhaps it was the pan I used. Instead of using a loaf pan, I used a bundt cake pan and there wasn't much volume to the cake.
Not too hard to make...However, the frosting recipe could use half the sugar (a little too sweet for my taste). Also, the whole frosting recipe could be halved because I was left with a whole bowl of frosting, which means I will have to waste that batch or make another carrot cake.
The cake, to me, cannot stand on its own. It needs the frosting, which is why I've tasted better...As stated earlier, with the frosting, the cake is not too bad...
I would give this a 3 out of 5 rating. Just OK.